Washington: Donald Trump faces a major foreign policy test
Monday night when he appears before the country's biggest pro-Israel lobby with
many of the 18,000 expected participants already questioning his Middle East
credentials and rhetoric.
He is one of four
presidential candidates scheduled to appear at the American Israel Public
Affairs Committee's three-day gathering, which kicked off with an address by
Vice President Joe Biden on
Sunday night. The annual ritual is part love fest, with a parade of politicians
reaffirming their pro-Israel bona fides, and wonk fest, with speakers getting
deep into the weeds on the Israeli-Palestinian peace process and U.S. military
and financial support for its closest Mideast ally.
Democrat Hillary Clinton and Republicans Ted Cruz and John Kasich will
also be trying to shore themselves up with Jewish voters and, particularly in
the case of GOP candidates, pro-Israel evangelicals. Bernie Sanders said last
week he won't attend the gathering, but Trump is the one who
has elicited the most skepticism -- and outright criticism -- so far.
In fact, Clinton
slammed the billionaire businessman in her address Monday morning, attacking
him for saying he would be "neutral" in the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict.
She didn't name Trump,
but it was clear she was referring to him when she said, "We need steady
hands, not a president who says he's neutral on Monday, pro-Israel on Tuesday
and who knows on Wednesday ... Israel's security is non-negotiable."
She continued,
"We can't be neutral when rockets rain down on residential neighborhoods,
when civilians are stabbed in the street. Some things aren't negotiable, and
anyone who doesn't understand that has no business being our president."
While Trump has
declared himself the most "pro-Israel" candidate out there, he hasn't
offered much detail on his policies, and audience members on both sides of the
partisan divide will be looking to his speech to see if he hits the notes they
hope to hear.
"He hasn't taken
any positions on Israel. He hasn't talked about specifics," said Nathan
Wurtzel, a Republican and co-founder of the Catalyst Group, a political
consultancy. "The Palestinian Authority won't even come to the table
without concessions from Israel. What's his position on that? I don't
know."
What Trump has said about Israel and issues of
importance to the Jewish community hasn't always been well received.
Already, several
Jewish organizations have slammed his rhetoric as hateful, condemned the
violence at his rallies and criticized his inclusion at AIPAC; a group of rabbis has
even called for boycotts of his speech Monday evening.
And his Israel
policies -- particularly vowing to be a "neutral guy" on the
Israeli-Palestinian peace process and suggesting that Israel lacks the
commitment to make a deal -- haven't all sat well with activists who want the
United States to be strongly on Israel's side.
Defending Trump's
record
Trump's campaign, however, strongly defended his stance on
Israel.
"Mr. Trump has a
long history of being a strong supporter of Israel," said spokeswoman Hope
Hicks in an email. "Mr. Trump has said, as President, there will be no one
stronger on Israeli-American relations than him, and his consistent support and
advocacy for Israel over many years is proof of this."
She also pointed to
him having "received numerous awards, participated in many events and made
significant contributions to a variety of Jewish related causes over the
years."
Trump was also the one
who started the Republican stampede to AIPAC, announcing that he wouldn't be
attending a debate in Utah on Monday night and would instead make "a very
major speech in front of a very important group of people."
Still, Israel is a
topic where Trump is a wild card, said Aaron David Miller, vice president at
the Wilson Center and a former State Department peace negotiator.
"He is
idiosyncratically different from any candidate seeking the Republican or Democratic
nomination when it comes to how he talks about Israel," Miller said.
Greg Rosenbaum,
chairman of the National Jewish Democratic Council, agreed that Cruz and
Clinton are better-known elements when it comes to Israel.
"I think the
stakes are very high for Trump, probably higher than they are for Cruz" or
Clinton, he said.
Cruz vs. Trump
Cruz is certainly hoping to draw blood.
The Texas senator
"will use his speaking opportunity to highlight Trump's positions -- or
lack thereof -- in front of the thousands of AIPAC members in attendance,"
his campaign announced Wednesday, "Including Trump's recent comments that
he would be 'neutral' in the debate between Israel and the Palestinians."
Cruz, a devout
Christian and pastor's son, will be courting evangelical voters as much as
Jewish ones. Evangelicals see the creation of Israel as
biblical prophecy and are adamantly against dividing the land in a peace
agreement with Palestinians.
As a voting bloc, though, they have
repeatedly favored Trump over Cruz as in Alabama, where 43% of evangelicals backed Trump in the primary
this month as opposed to 23% who supported Cruz. Cruz now lags in the delegate
count by 418 to 678 of the 1,237 needed to secure the nomination.
Cruz might try to
regain momentum among evangelical voters by touting his support for Israel,
blasting Trump's vague positions and then "taking that position back on the
trail to win back those evangelicals that he thought were naturally part of his
support," Rosenbaum said.
Trump has a tricky
line to walk, Rosenbaum added: "He is going to have a very difficult time
winning over the crowd if he doesn't take a more pro-Israel stance, and if he
does take a more pro-Israel stance, he's going to open himself up to charges of
flip-flopping and pandering that may also give Cruz ammunition."
Questions about where
Trump stands
Trump enters the room
Monday night already having created concern among supporters of Israel on
several fronts. Trump's declaration in a February town hall that he would be a
"neutral guy" in negotiating a Mideast peace deal "made a lot of
people uncomfortable," said Steve Rabinowitz, who runs a public relations
firm and once served in the Clinton White House.
And a few things he
has said have been controversial to the point of drawing boos from the
Republican Jewish Coalition in December.
He questioned whether
Israel really wants a peace deal, telling the coalition in December that he
didn't know "if Israel has the commitment."
He's also engaged in
"cringe-worthy" stereotypes, said Rosenbaum, pointing to Trump's
quips about Jews and money at the event. Trump told the attendees he knew they
wouldn't support him because he didn't want their money. "You want to
control your politicians," he said. "That's fine."
But it was his refusal
to tell the coalition whether he would move the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem that
drew jeers from the crowd.
Though a 1995 law
calls for transferring the embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, Republican and
Democratic presidents have consistently issued national security waivers to
prevent the move until there's a peace agreement between Israelis and
Palestinians, who both claim Jerusalem as their capital.
Others have pointed to
Trump statements that aren't even about Israel, including his December
suggestion that Muslims be barred from entering the United States.
The Union for Reform
Judaism issued a statement earlier in the week that said Trump's rhetoric
brought to mind the way Jews were blocked from entering America during World
War II, "with deadly consequences."
Trump has batted back
concerns about his commitment to Jewish issues and anti-Semitism by pointing to
his family. His daughter converted to Judaism to marry the son of a New York
real estate magnate, and his son married a Jewish woman.
Wurtzel, the
Republican political consultant, said he sees no anti-Semitism in Trump himself
but noted, "he's certainly attracted white supremacist, anti-Semitic
followers."
Describing Trump's
campaigning style as "power-hungry, nationalist, self-centered,"
Wurtzel added that "a Trump-led kind of government historically hasn't
been friendly to Jews."
Comments